Just in case it’s needed, this post is about a recent shooting, so skip reading it if it might affect you more than average.
Four days ago, there was a shooting at Evergreen High School in Evergreen, Colorado. It is among the latest incidents of what has become all too common. I got a reminder of how common it is while at a school recently during work and was looking at the design cut into 8 foot tall metal plates that turned the gates into shields. While there were critical injuries to some students at Evergreen, the only death was the shooter, who killed himself after he couldn’t get away fast enough.
You may not have heard about that because there was a famous person who was also killed that day. Charlie Kirk was the co-founder of Turning Point USA. He was speaking at a TPUSA public debate at Utah Valley University and was shot by a person who was located in a nearby building.
Conservatives and Republicans immediately knew what kind of person would have done it.
U.S. Representative Nancy Mace from South Caroline knew it was “some raging leftist lunatic” and told the reporters, “Democrats own this”. One reporter asked if that meant Republicans had to own the killing of the two Democrat politicians a few months ago. She was incensed. She’s talking about Charlie Kirk, right here, right now and don’t you dare try to distract from that. She also said at a different point, “It sounds like the shooter was some kind of tranny, pro tranny.” She phrases it as they might be that, but it’s clear she knows they are that.
Trump said the shooter would be from the radical left, because that’s his go-to for any problem of any kind, along with fake news, witch hunts, hoaxes, being persecuted, being persecuted so everyone else won’t be persecuted, etc. Speculation ensued. Was the shooter some kind of operative? Were they a professional killer? An agent of organized political violence? Are they part of an elaborate conspiracy involving the catch-all boogieman of antifa? Maybe it was “Kirk’s rivals in the MAGA sphere”? I didn’t know things were so bad in the MAGA sphere that Kirk might have had rivals that hated him that much.
Trump Jr goes into a hate-filled anti-transgender rant, saying, “name a mass shooting, uh, in the last year or two in America that wasn’t committed” by one who’s a lunatic and “has been pumped up on probably hormones since they were three”. Junior, given the number of times you’ve been on camera and had a jittery, frenetic appearance about you, accompanied by extremely rapid talking, it’s more likely you might be pumped up on something a little stronger than caffeine, rather than who you’re certain you know is the killer.
Then there was the inaccurate law enforcement bulletin originating with the AFT about what was found written on the recovered bullet casings. The engravings supposedly were “transgender and anti-fascist ideology”, which inferred the killer was connected to the LGBTQ+ community in some way. So of course, knowing exactly what kind of person the killer would be shifted in that direction. Later, it’s revealed that some of the “engravings” were the bullet manufacturer’s identification marks. So the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives suddenly doesn’t know how to identify who made a bullet? Actually, they might not since the head of the field office in Utah was fired a few weeks earlier and she was a very skilled and experienced person. She just had the bad luck of being a Pakistani and she was no longer a “good fit” for the office.
FBI director Kash Patel makes an official statement on Twitter: We got the guy!. A few hours later: The guy has been released after an investigation. Then he said later on: We got the guy this time! A few hours later: Not him, he’s been released.
Finally, the guy that actually committed the murder is in custody. Before I give the details about what kind of person the shooter is, here’s what Utah Governor Spencer Cox, Republican, said about what he hoped that person would be at the press conference about the suspect being in custody:
“You know, this, bad stuff happens. And for, for 33 hours, I was praying that, uh, that, um, if this had to happen here, that it wouldn’t be one of us. That somebody drove from another state, somebody came from another country. Sadly, that, that, that prayer was not answered the way I had hoped for. Just because I thought it would make it easier on us if we could just say, ‘Hey, we don’t do that here.’”
He then went on to describe some of the positive things the state of Utah has done. Behind him, Kash Patel is standing there, looking uneasy. In another video of the press conference, Patel is rapidly looking left and right, even more nervous and uneasy. He’d got it wrong twice. Very wrong.
Take a second and re-read Cox’s statement: He prayed the killer “wouldn’t be one of us.” He wanted them to be from somewhere outside of Utah, maybe from somewhere outside of the U.S. Because Americans shouldn’t do this to Americans, and especially not Utahns doing it to Utahns. Where have Republicans repeatedly been pushing as the source of all our problems? People from other countries.
So who did the killer turn out to be? One of their own.
After enough pictures and video were available and made public, the family of Tyler James Robinson began asking if that was him. He said it was. He’d also been asked by friends on Discord, but joked about a doppleganger trying to frame him, maybe the group can give him a cut of the FBI reward money if they were to turn him in, and pretended to be Kirk by saying he’d faked his own death to retire from political activism.
The information about how Robinson entered custody varies. One place says he turned himself in. Another (The Atlantic) says the parents called their pastor, who is also a court security officer with the U.S. Marshals Service, who then contacted a deputy marshal, who then came to the family home, then contacted federal law enforcement.
Whichever way it was, it wasn’t the FBI that found him and apprehended him. Kash Patel had a very high profile case dropped in his lap, and the agency he leads didn’t close the deal, even after Patel twice saying they had.
Despite what Governor Cox prayed it would be, the killer did turn out to be “one of us”. A white 22-year-old male, born and raised in a religious and conservative family that lives in Utah. He was registered to vote, but not for any specific party, and hadn’t voted yet.
The reaction has changed direction so suddenly it will give you whiplash. Remember the ones who were ready to flay the killer alive, who they knew for certain what evil group he was a part of? They’re now advocating prayer and compassion for the killer.
The narrative is also shifting to someone that is supposedly a roommate of Robinson that is supposedly cooperating with the FBI, even though Robinson was living at home with his parents, and that other someone once used a filter on a video two years ago to make him look like a female anime character, so that obviously means he’s transgender and he’s actually the reason why Kirk was killed, not Robinson.
Yet another example of hypocrisy and cognitive dissonance allowing people who know they’re right to twist things around so they can keep being right and to keep having a reason to hate others.